Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts

Thursday, September 12, 2019

A Catholic Perspective on Development

By Jacob C. Maichel

Development is a word that gets thrown around a lot and seems to get conflated with progress, or at least reduced to a strictly economic initiative. While there is an economic aspect, development needs to occur on many more areas to allow humans to flourish. Such areas include religious freedoms, the right to share in building society, the organizing and forming of unions, and the ability to take economic actions. These other aspects are just as, and likely more, important than meeting our material needs and wants. Without the ability to enjoy these privileges we are deprived of fulfillment. Pope John Paul II was very clear in Sollicitudo Rei Socialis that underdevelopment in any of these areas is detrimental to the human condition, as is over development that leads to consumerism and unfulfilling desires.

Four decades ago Pope John Paul II urged us to consider our relationship with goods, and perhaps we should have listened better. I think we have come to a point where goods are meant to simplify our lives and make things as easy and mindless as possible, whereas they should be tools to not only enrich our lives but further us along in our vocations. Pope Paul VI in Populorum Progressio offered us a new framework with which to view development, calling for the economies of the world to serve all mankind rather then the few. What Paul VI and John Paul II refer to as "authentic development" puts humanity at the center of development, serving as a morally preferable guide to growth. Seeing growth as purely economic, focusing only on GNP or GDP, completely ignores the spiritual dimensions of human existence. This disregard for the human can only be overcome with solidarity, not only between communities, but nations themselves.

Relationships among nations is a chief concern in achieving authentic development. Development is something that we must work together on, a common goal for all of humanity. The status quo of giving massive loans by multi-government organizations is actually hampering the growth of developing nations. Countries take on massive loans to fund all types of economic development, but then soon are bogged down by interest payments. To continue to improve or even maintain the quality of life more loans continually are taken out as countries struggle to service existing debt. For example, in 2017 $1.3 trillion was given in the form of loans or investments to developing nations while $3.3 trillion came back out to repay debts. Perhaps rather than just dumping money into countries we should allow them to create their own micro-financing institutions that support local small- to medium-sized businesses. Many entrepreneurs in developing countries lack access to important capital and are not large enough to attract foreign investment or traditional bank loans. Giving people in developing countries the tools to grow and support their own communities shows much more solidarity than usurious lending.

In addition to concerns about the human person, the largest concern for authentic development is environmental impact. Sollicitudo Rei Socialis reminds us that God has called on us to use the resources that have been gifted to us in this life. In Genesis we are called to live with creation and are granted dominion over the creatures Earth. In the parable of the talents we are again reminded to use our abilities and be fruitful with the limited resources God has given us. John Paul II gives us 3 important considerations regarding alteration of the environment:

  • Awareness that creation is not to be used however one wishes. Purely economic justifications are not sufficient to destroy creation.
  • Understanding that resources are limited. Not everything we have been given on this Earth is renewable and acting as such endangers future generations. Although we have been able to stay ahead of catastrophe with technological advancement everything has a natural limit.
  • Realization of the impact of development on the quality of life in developed zones. A great example of this is pollution that harms the health of entire populations.

This understanding of our relationship with the environment goes much further than trying to internalize negative externalities through regulation. Only when we comprehend that we are failing to act as good stewards of creation can we grasp the true severity of environmental abuse.

The solution to achieving authentic development is beginning to think of it as a human problem, rather than a technical problem. Seeing development as purely a technical problem that we can, through our own social, political, and technological means, solve removes the human from the equation, leading to very shortsighted and damaging pseudo-solutions. Traditional Church teaching offers knowledge that is not rooted in liberal capitalism or Marxist collectivism, but rather a response based on thousands of years of human history and divine revelation. By respecting cultures and putting the well-being of the human first we can overcome the detriments of purely economic development and instead see development as the new word for peace, just as Pope Paul VI called for back in 1967.

Jacob C. Maichel is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Sunday, July 28, 2019

Who Holds the Trump Card: Federal or State Goverments?

by Jacyn Dawes

Since the 1940s, Spades has been one of the most popular card games.  The premise of the game is to estimate how many hands you are going to win before the round begins.  The highest card wins, with the ace being the highest card, unless someone trumps it.

As the name suggests, spades are the trump cards.  Even if everyone plays a diamond, including the ace of diamonds, someone could swoop in with the two of spades and win the hand.  Whether it be card games or the classic “Go ask you mom” line, this idea of the trump card exists in our everyday lives.  One of the large-scaled examples of this is state versus federal laws.  Often, individual states can make decisions in their laws that contradict existing federal laws.  When this happens, who holds the ‘trump card?’

Some laws that the federal government handles include civil rights, immigration law, and social security.  Letting states implement their own laws is a way for the people to have laws that better represent their rights, especially since there are fewer people those laws represent.  Some state-decided topics include criminal issues, family matters, real estate, and business matters.  Local laws take this one step farther.  This does mean that there are many instances where the states implement a law that contradicts the government.  The big topic that comes to mind is marijuana.

More states are choosing to legalize marijuana, while the federal government has yet to make that step.  When situations like this happen, the federal government does have the king of spades card, called the Supremacy Clause.  As a part of the U.S. Constitution, the goal of the Supremacy Clause is not to tell states what laws to make, but rather give the federal government the ability to have the deciding vote when laws contradict.  This raises the question: why, then, are states allowed to pass these laws in the first place?

A lot of this can be directed back to enforcement.  Enforcement can cause a lot of gray area with the Supremacy Clause because that enforcement falls back on the federal government.  While states do not have to enforce the laws, they are also not allowed to stop federal authorities that are.  There is, however, one card that can trump the king of spades.  If the laws contradict, those under prosecution could take matters to the courts and attempt to declare the law unconstitutional.  The rights listed in the constitution hold the ultimate trump card, the ace of spades.  Overall, states have the ability to give their people rights that better represent them.  But at the end of the day, we are one nation.  As long as those laws remain constitutional, the federal government does have the deciding vote.

If you want to research federal and state laws, regulations, and court decisions, please visit https://www.usa.gov/how-laws-are-made.  On their website, they have links to many different resources such as the Code of Federal Regulations and the Law Library of Congress.

Bicycle (n.d.). How to Play: Spades.  Retrieved from https://bicyclecards.com/how-to-play/spades/

Daunt, L. (2014, Mar 30). State vs. Federal Law: Who Really Holds the Trump Card? Huffington Post. Retrieved from https://www.huffpost.com/entry/state-vs-federal-law-who_b_4676579

Diffen (n.d.). Federal vs. State Law. Retrieved from https://www.diffen.com/difference/Federal_Law_vs_State_Law

Levy, R. (2013, Mar 18). Yes, States Can Nullify Some Federal Laws, Not All. Cato Institute. Retrieved from https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/yes-states-can-nullify-some-federal-laws-not-all

Roberts, C. & Martin, R. (2018, Mar 15). What Happens When States Defy Federal Laws. NPR.  Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/2018/03/14/593398902/what-happens-when-states-defy-federal-laws

Striepe, B. (n.d.). What Happens When a State Law Contradicts a U.S. Federal Law? Retrieved from https://people.howstuffworks.com/state-law-contradicts-federal-law.htm

USA Gov (n.d.).  How Laws are Made and How to Research Them.  Retrieved from https://www.usa.gov/how-laws-are-made

Jacyn Dawes is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

What's wrong with economic freedom in Guatemala?

by Russ McCullough

I am excited to be traveling to Guatemala with my wife and son in August! My wife helps run a non-profit called Education and More there where the organization contracts with local indigenous women to produce products that use the hand-woven fabric that has been made for centuries there. Generational poverty is an issue there where subsistence living is the norm. The proceeds from sales in the United States and donations fund a fair wage to the women in addition to private schooling for their children through high school and even college for those who go. It is a fabulous organization and please visit https://www.educationandmore.org/ to learn more and donate if you want to support what they do.

The Gwartney Institute investigates reasons why some countries are poor and others are rich. It turns out that Economic Freedom is highly negatively correlated with poverty. Countries with a high degree of economic freedom have less poverty. The Fraser Institute publishes the Economic Freedom of the World (EFW) Index each year, its lead author is Dr. Jim Gwartney for which our Institute was named. I was shocked to learn that the most recent ranking of Guatemala was 23rd in the world for economic freedom, tied with Finland! Income per person adjusted for purchasing power parity in Finland was $43,700 in Finland during this time while it was only $8,000 in Guatemala (it was $57,900 in the USA). The average income for countries in the top 25% of the EFW index is $42,500 and the average for the bottom 25% was $6,500.
 
This did not make sense to me, so I began to investigate why Guatemala is so poor relative to its high EFW ranking. I found a plausible reason for the discrepancy by diving deeper into the way the EFW index value is calculated and then reconciling it with Guatemala’s area scores. There are five primary areas of the EFW index; 1) size of government, 2) legal system and property rights, 3) sound money, 4) freedom to trade internationally, and 5) regulation. Within each of these five areas, data is collected from many objective external sources and then each area receives a score out of 10. A simple average is used to compute the overall score (click here for details). The beauty of this formula is that a single number now objectively reflects the compilation of 42 variables for every country with data available. However, this is precisely what causes some countries to be ranked higher than what seems they should.

A country that is weak in ‘Area 2 -legal system and property rights’ may not be very free at all. Is anarchy true freedom? No, freedom is not the absence of government. Individual freedom can only be achieved with proper constraints on other people’s behavior to do no harm to others. Indeed, “do whatever you want as long as you don’t hurt someone else” is a philosophy that contributes to individual freedom. While the simple average of the areas gives us a transparent way to calculate the overall EFW, I would argue that Guatemala presents a case that shows how important Area 2 is for low income countries. It shows how the EFW index can be used to determine policy recommendations to raise people out of poverty.

The other area of the index that makes Guatemala rank higher than it should is ‘Area 1 -size of government’. The index suggests to me that the government sector is too small, specifically the sub-areas of Government Consumption and Transfers and Subsidies are too low relative to other countries in the top 25%. As a free-market economist, I find this a bit difficult to write.

However, I think it makes sense given that Guatemala has the best score for both of those sub-areas of all countries in the top 25% which means they spend the least amount of money relative to country income. Those sub-areas simply look at the fraction of government spending to Gross Domestic Product. It looks to me that Guatemalan government needs to do more work on ‘legal system and property rights’ and this likely means more government spending in that area. There is an optimal level of government spending to maintain a healthy rule of law. If spending is too low, vital functions of the government are underfunded. By looking at the outcomes in Guatemala, they are apparently not doing enough to get the wealth-creating engine of capitalism going strongly.

I did a little modification to the sub-areas to see where Guatemala would rank if it was doing the average level of government spending done by countries in the top 25%. By replacing just these two numbers, Guatemala’s EFW overall score falls to 7.28 which drops its ranking to 54 (the 2nd quartile) which is sandwiched between the Slovak Republic and Italy. Since the average income in the 2nd quartile is $20,200, I am not sure it has dropped enough. The average income in the 3rd quartile is $14,300! 

That’s enough of the numbers, I don’t want your head to spin. The measurement of economic freedom is a complex topic but the general results we find from research using the EFW index paints a clear picture that economic freedom is key to getting the social outcomes we all desire. Where economic freedom is strongest, there is less poverty, better access to drinking water, longer life expectancy, lower infant mortality, better gender equity –the list goes on and on and is compelling. I hope that my visit to Guatemala will further inform me of other policy recommendations that can lead to more human flourishing there.

Dr. Russ McCullough is the Founder & Director of the Gwartney Institute and the Wayne Angell Chair in Economics at Ottawa University

Thursday, May 30, 2019

China Tariff Battle Impacts Ottawa Kansas

by Levi A. Russell
This originally appeared as a column at the Ottawa Herald

When we read about the many aspects of the current trade war with China, it’s difficult to see how big international policy decisions affect us here in Ottawa. This week I’d like to discuss recent events in the trade war with China and how they might affect us. To do that, let’s take a big picture look at the trade war. Though there are many weapons in a trade war, tariffs are the primary weapon of choice for the Trump administration in its war with China. A tariff is a tax on an import, but as we will see, it’s a complicated tax.

Earlier this month, the U.S. Trade Representative imposed a 25% tariff on $200 billion worth of Chinese goods imported to the U.S. The 25% tariff is paid explicitly by importers of Chinese goods, but other parties are implicitly affected by the tax. In economics, we say that the incidence of the tax falls on the aforementioned importers, Chinese exporters, and U.S. consumers. The importer passes on some or all of the tariff in the form of higher prices for U.S. consumers. This higher price pushes down the quantity that consumers want to buy, resulting in lower revenue for Chinese exporters.

The tariffs will be applied to over 5,000 different products; some are consumer goods (i.e. goods we buy and consume directly) and others are intermediate goods, which are used by U.S. manufacturers to make other products. Some examples of goods that will be taxed under this tariff are grain, candies, pasta, beverages, minerals, ores, slag, ash, mineral oils, inorganic chemicals used in manufacturing, fertilizers, soaps, plastics, rubber, wood, fabric, stone, ceramics, flax, cotton, wool, aluminum, furniture, clocks, ships and boats, electronics, and many other goods. We can expect that the prices of many of the consumer goods listed here will increase here in the U.S. and the prices of other goods made from the intermediate goods will also rise to some extent (though not likely a full 25%).

A few days after the U.S. Trade Representative announced the 25% tariff, China retaliated with a promise to increase tariffs on $60 billion worth of goods exported to China. These tariffs will directly impact importers in China, but will also affect industries in the U.S. that export to China, as well as Chinese consumers. The broad categories of goods that will fall under these higher tariffs are food products, building materials, furniture, bedding, footwear, clocks, light fixtures, musical instruments, parts for locomotives, boats and yachts, electronics, and chemicals.

Here in Ottawa, the U.S. tariffs will likely have a bigger impact than the Chinese tariffs. Like the rest of the country, we will likely see a rise in the prices of many consumer goods. Some of the manufacturing and construction businesses in Ottawa will likely see an increase in their costs, especially if they buy raw materials or intermediate products directly from China. They will either have to pay higher prices for these inputs or find other sources either in the U.S. or another country.

Even though I am an economist, I will not try to tell you all of this is bad. The expected reductions in employment and GDP in the U.S. are mild, though they will likely be felt to a greater degree in specific areas of the country. These economic costs might be worth it if they result in policy changes that are favorable to U.S. interests. For all its improvements in the past few decades since it slaughtered tens of millions of its own people, China is still a Communist country. They still send Christians and Muslims to “re-education camps,” micromanage their citizens’ lives with an authoritarian social credit system, and support North Korea, which actively tortures its own people. China has repeatedly stolen our intellectual property and is increasing its spying efforts in the U.S.

The use of the term “trade war” is apt. The tariff battles may impact the economy in the short run, but winning the war is the goal. It’s up to us and our elected officials to determine whether the economic costs are worth the strategic and security-related benefits.

Dr. Levi A. Russell is the Gwartney Institute Professor of Economic Education and Research at Ottawa University

Wednesday, May 22, 2019

Market Solutions: Infrastructure Problems

Jacob C. Maichel 
It is hard to deny that healthy transportation infrastructure and support systems are paramount to economic growth and success. Unfortunately American roads and highways systems are crumbling more and more by the day and no matter how much the government spends the trend does not seem to shift. A study by the American Society of Civil Engineers determined that 32% of urban roads are in extremely poor condition, with Kansas having the 5th worst roads in the United States1! What can we do to fix our continually deteriorating roads? 
The right answer is not continuing to pour billions of federal dollars into infrastructure projects, atleast without private partnerships. The Trump administration in their 2018 budget proposal meetings began to increase federal spending on infrastructure by $200 billion which continued to undermine the power of American decentralization3. Federal spending and regulation will continue to hamper private responses to these problems if there is not a significant shift in federal policy.  
One of the first barriers is effect that the heavy red tape of regulation is having on development as a whole. Not too long ago in 1970 mandated reviews by the National Environmental Protection Act took an average of 2.2 years while today we are looking at around 6.6 years on the low end2! In the same timeframe we have seen environmental laws raise from only 26 to 70 in total when it comes to infrastructure development3. I am all for the environment but I am also for progress. Instead of the government pouring money into infrastructure perhaps they could spend it elsewhere to bolster environmental protections and cut back regulations allowing states or private industry take over. This way projects could be determined by supply and demand and the most pressing concerns can be addressed first by the people that use the systems, rather than bureaucracy! 
A major factor that prevents someone else from taking the reins from the federal government is the distortion caused by subsidies which reduces other projects return on investment. American investment banks and large pension funds seek to invest in infrastructure projects but often turn to foreign development particularly in Canada, Asia, and Latin America2. Instead of a top down approach the power should be given to states and allow private public partnerships. This is currently difficult to do as any project that receives any federal funds must return all the grant money if it decides to go private. States have also learned to become willingly helpless as they just hold out until roads become so bad the federal government has to pay for the repairs themselves. 
The fact of the matter is that private or local governments are able to do projects exceedingly more efficient. Federal projects have a long track record of having pork barrel spending tied to projects, usually a product of political favors completely removed from the people the project is meant to serve3. Not only have private projects both in and outside of the US been completed cheaper and faster they also remove all the risk from the taxpayer and shift it to the investors backing the project. These projects also create new revenue for the federal government instead of sucking out an ever growing amount of money.  
Something that should very seriously be considered is allowing all 50 states to collect toll revenue from interstate systems and use it to maintain the roads. This has worked incredibly well for India’s toll road which is one of the busiest systems in the world2. Allowing states to tap into this capital to modernize and maintain roads would be a very welcomed shift by anyone who uses these roads on their daily commutes. If the states also had the ability to team up with local innovators they could completely transform the way infrastructure is managed. Economies of scale can help private investors to offset large investments while trying to earn a return, incentivizing efficient allocation of resources.  
The fact remains that the more power is given to the private sector and smaller localized governments the better the results are. If the federal government was able to produce cheaper high quality infrastructure it would make sense for them to control all the means of production… which has failed in every socialist country in the history of humankind. State and local governments should be encouraged to collaborate with the same people they served rather than penalized for taking part in building up their communities. Page Break 

  1. Chris Edwards, “Privatization,” https://www.downsizinggovernment.org, Cato Institute, July 12, 2016.

     Jacob C. Maichel is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Wednesday, May 8, 2019

Market Solutions: Transport Safety

By Jacob C. Maichel

Anyone who has flown within the last two decades understands how frustrating the process can be. Arriving hours earlier than takeoff to combat the setbacks that could prevent you from making your flight is frustrating. It seems the security model provided by the government has no alternative, but what if private industry had more freedom to do screenings? Surely companies with an incentive to outperform their rivals would be a more efficient solution than the Transportation Security Administration (TSA).

Previous to one of the most devastating acts of terrorism, 9/11, the majority of airport security was handled by private companies. The issue with the previous model was that the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) oversaw the private companies. Before 9/11 the majority of the rules set in place by the FAA were to protect against plane malfunctions or natural disasters, as they had little desire to be a law enforcement agency1. After the attacks congress unanimously approved a fully federal screening system which created the TSA in 2001. By 2002 the TSA was based in the Department of Homeland Security and boasted the 4th largest budget in the building. A fully federal system was actually opposed by then president George W. Bush and the House of Representatives, who both pushed for private security with strict federal oversight.

There is a small program called the Screening Partnership Program (SPP) that meets much resistance from the TSA. The SPP program allows for airports to opt in for private screeners rather than the traditional TSA approach and currently 22 airports take advantage of this. One of the largest adopters of this is the San Francisco airport. A study by the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee revealed in 2011 that screening inside of San Francisco International was 65% more efficient than federal screening at Los Angeles. Some of the factors that are attributed to this dominance is less employee turnover which leads to better workers, and more flexible staffing measures such as scheduling.

San Francisco really exhibited the benefits of being private during the recent government shutdown. During the shutdown TSA employees calling in sick increased 272%, while none of the 22 privatized airports had any delays. Being private also allows for more focus to be on the security of the consumer. In 2015 there was a test by the inspector general where 67/70 weapons made it past TSA screening points. If this happened to a private service provider the airline could simply switch to new security. For private screeners being effective is the only way to stay in the airports, as where TSA is guaranteed.

One of the most glaring flaws in this structure to me is that the TSA is self regulating. TSA has the task to give themselves their own rules which creates a conflict of interest. The TSA gets to choose what is and is not allowed on airplanes, what technology and screening procedures are used, all while being the same organization who implement the searches! With private screeners we could hold each company accountable, decrease operating costs, and most importantly increase security! While federal oversight is unquestionably important in aviation the security itself could be handled much better by the private sector.

Jacob C. Maichel is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Monday, April 29, 2019

Market Solutions - Disaster Response

By Jacob C. Maichel

Economists such as Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek, and Milton Friedman have proclaimed the pitfalls of central planning, but their message has not been heard with regard to disaster management. One of the most glaring shortcomings can be seen in The Federal Management Agency (FEMA). FEMA is the government organization tasked with coordinating and leading disaster relief efforts. While this sounds good, the relief programs operated by the government are often disasters themselves. We have seen time and time again where the private sector responds more effectively than the government. 

One of the first things to point out is the significant waste both monetarily and in relief supplies. After Katrina, we saw case after case of fraud that resulted in over $2 billion in taxpayer money being wasted in false claims. Examples such as a Texas hotel owner collecting $232,000 in bills for phantom victims or 1,100 prisoners receiving more than $10 million in rental and disaster relief highlight taxpayer money being taken from those who needed it. In 2018 we witnessed extreme mismanagement of aid that was intended for the victims of hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico. It was revealed there were government parking lots with food rotting in the boxes, which themselves were covered with rat feces. FEMA 91,000 tons of ice intended for disaster victims to the wrong state! The situation became so hopeless that Puerto Rican officials asked for aid to be exclusively in the form of money and personnel.

Most importantly the free market provides care for victims significantly better than the government does. Louisiana understands this better than most. In 2005 over 1,500 residents tragically perished in hurricane Katrina, many waiting on government alleviation from the flood waters or needed supplies. In 2016 when floods threatened Louisiana it’s people responded much different. Local efforts saved lives far before any government assistance ever arrived. Facebook groups sprang up to coordinate supply deliveries and rescue efforts. The “Cajun Navy” was created by people using private boats to rescue those in their communities. Phone applications with walkie talkie and GPS functions were utilized to help those who were in need.

Not only has FEMA been considerably less successful than private efforts, the organization significantly hampers non government relief assistance. During disasters it is commonplace to see miles of retail truck convoys carrying precious life-saving supplies stopped by FEMA as to not interfere with their government strategies. During Katrina buses belonging to private businesses who were relocating displaced victims were requisitioned and instead used to deliver people to the New Orleans Convention Centre. Many more deaths were caused by this as the convention center lacked many basic needs yet people were continually placed there by FEMA efforts. When left unhindered local businesses actions have been significantly more successful in getting much needed supplies into communities. When hurricane Sandy struck it hit 295 Walmart stores, 250 were open the next day. Local churches and charities are always the first ones of the ground to help the victims of catastrophe and support their communities.

Unfortunately FEMA even negatively impacts local efforts by disincentivizing charitable giving and creating free trade zones. Public aid creates the illusion that there is a diminished need to give to charities who act during disasters. The organizations that provide the most benefit are the same ones that FEMA hurts. Impact on local business should also be considered as well. FEMA creates free trade zones where normal market conditions vanish. Licenses and taxes which protect sellers and buyers are suspended and businesses have less motivation to provide needed goods and services. Business' motivation for helping may involve profit but being able to survive is priceless.

When FEMA leaves an area after a disaster, business’ drive for profit and free markets are largely responsible for rebuilding. Companies will sell raw materials to others begin to rebuild. Private businesses will repair homes and infrastructure while taking payment for this all while hiring displaced workers for these projects. It was in fact for profit app developers and Facebook that created the tools the Cajun Navy used in saving their own communities. Government responsibility in disaster should be to reopen infrastructure that supports trade and to continue securing property rights rather than be the hero that saves us. Historically we have been let down time and time again by FEMA’s efforts whereas the free market left to its own devices has helped communities come together and rise out of devastating situations.

Jacob C. Maichel is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Thursday, April 11, 2019

Are We Morally Permitted to Eat Animals?

by Jacob C. Maichel

The Gwartney Institute just held its most recent “Ottawa Minds and Unwined” and it was the first one I have been able to attend. The speaker for this event was a philosophy professor, Dr. Justin Clarke, and the title of his presentation was “Are we morally permitted to eat animals?” I was excited to hear Dr. Clarke’s take on an interesting topic and it offered a unique and refreshing perspective. I wrote this post based on the speech because I thought it was fantastic!

The speech began by laying a foundation describing assertions from Australian philosopher Peter Singer’s famous 1975 book Animal Liberation: A New Ethics for our Treatment of Animals. This work has become the basis of the modern animal liberation movement’s understanding of humanity's relationship with animals. Once Singer established animals are capable of suffering he takes a very utilitarian approach to minimize said suffering in animals and humans alike. Dr. Clarke outlined 4 premises and 2 conclusions:

Premise 1: All suffering is equal (morally)

Premise 2: Animal experimentation causes unnecessary suffering.

Conclusion 1:Animal experimentation should stop unless we would do the same experiments on humans.

Premise 3: Animal consumption causes unnecessary suffering.

Premise 4: We are morally required to feed ourselves in a way to minimize suffering.

Conclusion 2: We should be vegetarian or vegan.

Once these were explained, Dr. Clarke then began to give evidence to support premise 2 and 3 in particular. For premise 2, he pointed to a number of past and recent experiments that were extremely damaging to animals. Support for premise 3 comes from the atrocities that occur in so-called factory farming, suggesting we should eat in a way that minimizes animal suffering. The needless suffering inherent in meat diets suggests a moral hierarchy of diets:

Least suffering: Vegetarian/Vegan

Omnivore 

Most suffering is carnivore

Dr. Clarke then dives farther in giving a in depth ranking of suffering caused by diet which goes;

Most preferable: Vegan

   Vegetarian

   Pescertarian (fish only)

   Principled Omnivore (looks into how the animals are raised, i.e. eats free range)

   Plebian Omnivore (does not care where meat comes from)

Least preferable: Carnivore 

Veganism surely causes less suffering to animals than a monster carnivorous diet, right? According to Dr. Clarke, that is incorrect! His list would actually go

Most preferable: Principled Omnivore

    Vegan

    Vegetarian

    Pescatarian

    Plebian Omnivore

Least Preferable: Carnivore

How can this be true? Dr. Clarke’s point was that we treat vegan and vegetarian diets as if they do not cause suffering, which is false. Evidence of this is shown by analyzing the per 100kg usable protein in pastured cattle production vs grain production. For cattle there are 2.2 deaths per 100kg, compared to 55 deaths for the same amount of protein in grain! Dr. Clarke pointed out the gruesome end these animals suffer in the grain production process.

The victims of grain production are mice which are often discounted by many people but these animals sing to their young and have at least the same capacity for suffering as chickens.  Therefore, if it is true that all suffering is equal, principled omnivores cause the least amount of suffering (ahead of vegans!). Does that mean everyone should become a principled omnivore according to Dr. Clarke? No! This is because premise four is not true according to him.

Dr. Clarke himself makes four well drawn conclusions in his fantastic presentation. First is that suffering surely counts, but not equally. Next there are better and worse ways to eat. Third is that we are not morally all required to eat the best way but should be conscious of eating in better ways. Lastly, if all this is correct Dr. Clarke says we can “put down our pitchforks," although for some it may be more difficult than others.

Dr. Clarke’s speech is part of a recurring Gwartney Institute event held at UnWined at Studio 111 which brings in a new speaker the first Thursday every month. The presentations are about 20 minutes in length with questions and optional conversation after. Please join us next time when Professor Jaime Fuentes will be speaking about Bitcoin!

 Jacob C. Maichel is a Graduate Assistant at the Gwartney Institute and an MBA student at Ottawa University

Thursday, April 4, 2019

The Importance of Trade to Local Economies

by Levi A. Russell

This post originally appeared in the Ottawa Herald.

In my last column, I made what I think was the best case for “buy local” and economics professor can make. Supporting your local community is a very important part of being a good citizen and a smart risk manager, but are there exceptions? Are there cases in which it might be sensible to support trade from other places? I think there are, and I’ll explain two cases in this column.

The first case is relatively straightforward: you can’t grow coconuts in Kansas. Unless you have a sophisticated network of firms operating in concert under multiple nations’ laws to bring about international trade (or a very strong barn swallow that recently flew south for the winter), you can’t buy coconuts here in Ottawa. The network that brings our soybeans to Japan and their cars back here is responsible for giving us a wide range of products we would not enjoy otherwise.

The second case takes a bit more thought. The production of many goods we enjoy couldn’t happen without investment in large-scale operations that may supply goods for consumers or other businesses over a large area. A simple example will help us get started.

Suppose you want to have pizza for supper. You might have all the ingredients you need at home and likely have an oven that will bake the crust nice and crispy. While this might work well for you, it might be nice if you could get someone else to make the pizza for you. Maybe you’re short on time or didn’t want to pay a lot of money for high-quality cheese at the grocery store. Maybe you’re just not a great pizza chef.

Another option would be to order the pizza from someone else. A pizza restaurant very likely has a large, expensive, specialized oven and a very large refrigerator filled with ingredients. These pieces of equipment allow the restaurant’s employees to efficiently make hundreds of pizzas per day; certainly more than the employees themselves could eat.

This large-scale production is great for all of us who enjoy pizza because it means the owners and employees can specialize in making pizzas and can buy ingredients at a lower cost per pound than the rest of us are able on our weekly trip to the store. The restaurant’s specialization and lower cost means the rest of us can enjoy tasty food on demand.

The comparison between household production and specialized production enabled by investment in fixed assets like commercial pizza ovens helps us understand the second exception to our buy local rule: sometimes the cost of production is too high for local production. Sometimes it’s so high it outweighs the benefits of local commerce I laid out in my last column.

Consider an example from our own backyard, Kalmar Ottawa. Kalmar Ottawa has been in business for over 60 years and has produced over 65,000 “terminal trucks” which are low-speed trucks used to move trailers around at shipping terminals. It is the leading producer of these trucks, which are all manufactured here in Ottawa and sold through dealers around the country.

Given the specialized knowledge and expensive machinery needed to manufacture these trucks, it wouldn’t be sensible to expect a shipping terminal to produce them on their own. It also wouldn’t make sense for there to be dozens of smaller manufacturing facilities all over the country making these trucks. No, we can all benefit when these trucks are made in one larger facility. It minimizes the cost of production and allows all the knowledge needed to be located in one place to maximize efficiency in production.

In addition to the benefits associated with the jobs and other commerce generated by Kalmar Ottawa, we also benefit indirectly from Kalmar Ottawa’s centralized production of their trucks. The coconuts we ship from the tropics get here a little more efficiently and at a little bit lower cost thanks to Kalmar Ottawa’s efficient business model. Whether those coconuts end up in a pina colada or a cream pie, I think we can all appreciate this exception to buying local.

Dr. Levi A. Russell is the Gwartney Institute Professor of Economic Education and Research at Ottawa University

Thursday, March 28, 2019

Economics of "Buy Local"

by Levi A. Russell

This post originally appeared in the Ottawa Herald.

On March 7th, the Gwartney Institute hosted a debate on the Ottawa University campus. I won’t name my opponent, but the two of us debated the following resolution: “Buy Local” is a Bad Idea. My opponent has no problem with shopping at local stores; our disagreement was about the economic soundness of preferring local stores even when they don’t deliver low prices or superior quality.

In the debate, I defended the following idea: It makes good economic sense to support local businesses if we consider the possible risks associated with not buying local. By “local businesses,” I don’t necessarily mean small sole proprietorships located exclusively within a town. From my view, supporting big box stores and franchises in your community is an integral part of a sensible version of “buy local.” After all, the managers, employees, and franchise owners are also part of your local community!

Here’s why: commerce builds community, and community brings security. We don’t have to look far to see communities that have declined economically to the point that they are struggling to maintain basic services. Hospitals are closing, schools are turning into nursing homes, and home values are dropping in areas that once supported thriving communities. Is there something we can do to prevent this decline?

Certainly there are instances in which the economic factors that contribute to the decline of a town or community within a larger city are inevitable. However, this is not always the case. The presence of entertainment and retail businesses in a locality is as important as organized events to fostering an atmosphere of community. It’s difficult to keep or attract new residents when these businesses leave.

So, shopping at local stores isn’t just something you do to avoid buying gas more frequently. It’s an important part of keeping your community together. Even if you might pay a somewhat higher price or face a slightly narrower selection, support of these businesses is very much in your own interest.

Consider this simple example. If you and a large percentage of the people in your community buy all your jewelry in a different city or online, the local jewelry store may not be able to stay in business. That may be fine, you think, if you were able to get a good deal on the jewelry you purchased. What happens, though, if a piece of your jewelry breaks? Now you either have to go out of your way to get it fixed or mail it off. Simply put, local businesses provide services that cannot be replicated.

Even more importantly, local businesses ensure the continued provision of large-scale services in your community such as hospitals and schools. This support of large-scale services goes beyond paying taxes. When commerce dwindles in a community, people leave. When people leave, medical and educational services must be consolidated because they aren’t financially viable on a small scale. These consequences are as evident in many rural areas as they are in big cities like Detroit.

A crucial part of building and maintaining community is local commerce. If you are financially able, don’t let short-term convenience get in the way of your willingness to contribute to your community’s long-term stability.

Dr. Levi A. Russell is the Gwartney Institute Professor of Economic Education and Research at Ottawa University